Honey and powdered sugar are two popular sweeteners with distinct characteristics. Honey, produced by bees through the gathering and refinement of plant secretions, serves as nourishment for bee colonies. On the other hand, powdered sugar, also known as confectioners’ sugar or icing sugar, undergoes a milling process to transform granulated sugar into a powdery form, often with the addition of an anti-caking agent.
With their unique properties, one may wonder: which sweetener reigns supreme? Let’s explore the qualities and benefits of each to determine the ultimate choice.
Comparing Powdered Sugar vs Honey
| Powdered Sugar | Honey | |
| Substitution ratio | n/a | n/a |
| Gluten-free? | Usually, yes, check labels! | Yes |
| Keto-friendly? | No | No |
| Paleo-friendly? | No | Raw and unpasteurized |
| Common Allergens | Sugarcane, cornstarch | Honey, some pollens |
| Pantry shelf life (unopened/sealed) | 4 plus years | Indefinite |
| Best for baking | Making icing and dusting pastries and baked goods | Flaky pastries and desserts, as a drizzle on baked goods. |
Differences Between Powdered Sugar And Honey
Pure, raw honey is a natural sweetener with numerous health benefits. It possesses antibacterial and anti-inflammatory properties, making it a popular choice among health-conscious individuals. The wide variety of honey available results from the different types of flowers the bees pollinate.
Composed mainly of sugars – approximately 40% fructose and 30% glucose – honey also contains water (17%) and other sugars, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals. Beyond its role as a sweetener, honey is valued for its medicinal properties. It is used as an anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and antibacterial agent. Many people consume honey orally to help alleviate coughs, while it is also applied topically to treat burns and promote wound healing.
Powdered sugar is not quite as versatile. It is essentially granulated white sugar ground into a fine powder. While granulated sugar feels sandy and coarse, powdered sugar has an almost chalky texture due to its finely pulverized form.
Powdered sugar finds everyday use in industrial food production when a sugar that dissolves quickly is required. For home cooks, it is primarily used to make icing, frosting, and other cake decorations. It is also often sprinkled onto baked goods to add a subtle sweetness and decoration.
Taste and Culinary Uses
When it comes to honey, its flavor profile goes beyond sweetness alone. Depending on the nectar source, honey can possess floral, fruity, smoky, woody, spicy, nutty, or earthy notes. These can enhance sweet and savory recipes like casseroles, sauces, and dressings.
Powdered sugar, also known as confectioners’ or icing sugar, brings a smooth, powdery texture and a sweet taste to desserts and beverages. It is commonly used for dusting desserts, thickening frostings, and sweetening beverages. In addition to these classic applications, powdered sugar can be used to decorate cakes and cookies and make royal icing. You can also use it to coat doughnuts and marshmallows!
Are Powdered Sugar and Honey Substitutes for Each Other?
Powdered sugar and honey are not suitable substitutes for each other unless you want to drizzle a baked good with honey instead of dusting it with powdered sugar. While they both provide sweetness, honey has a rich and earthy flavor distinct from powdered sugar’s familiar taste. Plus, the texture of honey is dense, while powdered sugar is light and fluffy. Therefore, it’s best to use either one or the other, depending on your dish.
Nutritional Profile And Health Benefits
- Name: Honey
- Serving size: 1 tbsp.
- Calories: 60
- Total carbs: 17 g
- Sugars: 17 g
- GI: 58
- Name: Powdered sugar
- Serving size: ¼ cup
- Calories: 120
- Total carbs: 30 g
- Sugars: 29 g
- GI: 65
Honey, with its phytochemical, anti-inflammatory, antimicrobial, and antioxidant properties, can potentially be used in disease treatment. It contains flavonoids and polyphenols, which function as antioxidants, supporting overall wellness. Powdered sugar serves as a quick energy source due to its simple carbohydrate composition, providing an instant boost when needed, but aside from this, it is not nutritionally beneficial. Because it is made from refined white sugar, all the naturally occurring vitamins and minerals have been stripped away.
Diet Suitability
Honey is not considered vegan due to its origin and production process. Bees collect nectar from flowers, partially digest it, and regurgitate it in their hives to store it in honeycombs. This rich source of sugars and carbohydrates serves as a long-lasting food for the hive. Consuming honey can disrupt ketosis, making it unsuitable for those following a ketogenic diet. While unadulterated raw honey aligns with the principles of a paleo lifestyle as a whole food, pasteurized honey undergoes heat processing, making it unsuitable for a paleo-oriented diet. Whole30 dieters must avoid any sweetening agents except fruit juice, so honey is also not Whole30 compliant.
Powdered sugar, on the other hand, raises different considerations depending on its origin. If the original sugar used to produce powdered sugar is refined cane sugar, it would not be considered vegan-friendly. However, if the original sugar used is vegan-friendly, such as beet sugar, the resulting powdered sugar would also be considered vegan, as cornstarch, the typical anti-caking agent used, is almost always vegan-friendly. Powdered sugar is not suitable for keto diets due to its high carbohydrate content, and powdered sugar is not recommended when following a paleo diet or Whole30 diet.
How to Store Powdered Sugar and Honey
Store honey in sealed glass jars with airtight lids to prevent air exposure when not in use. Avoid using non-food plastic or metal containers, as they can lead to honey oxidation. Powdered sugar can last indefinitely by storing it in an airtight container in a cool, dry place away from heat and strong odors.
Price and Availability
Honey prices start at $2.96 per pound for the commercially processed varieties and can vary significantly. Powdered sugar is typically priced at $2.50 per pound or higher. Both are easily found at supermarkets.
Environmental Impact
Regarding greenhouse gas emissions, honey production through beekeeping stands out as one of the lowest-impact options in food production. Unlike other farming practices, beekeeping doesn’t require large machines or fertilizers. This makes honey a sustainable and natural choice, with a relatively simple process from hive to cupboard.
On the other hand, powdered sugar production has a significant environmental impact. Sugar cane and sugar beets, the crops used for sugar production, require vast amounts of water and often rely on pesticides and fertilizers. Sugar mills generate wastewater, emissions, and solid waste, contributing to soil and water pollution. Additionally, the decomposition of plant matter and sludge from mills in freshwater bodies can deplete oxygen, leading to the death of marine life.
Powdered Sugar vs. Honey: The Ultimate Verdict
If I am looking purely for a sweetening agent, I’ll take honey over powdered sugar any day. However, if I am making icing for something, then only powdered sugar will do! So, while honey is superior, powdered sugar has uses that honey cannot fill. The verdict is dependent on the recipe!
FAQs
Can I replace sugar with honey for weight loss?
Neither honey nor sugar are the most ideal option for individuals seeking to shed weight. You are better off looking into natural, non-caloric sweeteners.
Does sugar or honey last longer?
When stored correctly, honey can remain edible for many years or even decades, while sugar can endure indefinitely if shielded from moisture and heat.
Links on this page may be affiliate links, for which the site earns a small commission, but the price for you is the same
